"Time out" never worked for my son, who has Asperger(a smart form of autism), and he always enjoyed to be alone. "Time out" will become an excuse for him for not interact with other family members. I can not afford to ground him either, because he will loose valuable oppertunities to build up his social skills. I do find that "time out" outside but near house(such as garage or deck) to be effective. However, it is hard to judge if any of these discipline cause long term psychological damages. The big lesson to teach is to take responsibility of own behavior and choice.
蔡真妮 發表評論於
回複fannie的評論:
謝謝你的分享,向你學習,我想我的耐心還是不夠。
fannie 發表評論於
這裏有很多錯誤的地方。
把孩子鎖起來,把孩子嚇住,把孩子拖到衛生間,使孩子哭的很凶,罰站還要Stick Nose To Wall,其實已經造成虐待甚至侮辱,我是舍不得也做不出來的。
孩子生下來是不會無理取鬧,屢教不改的,變成這樣都是大人的責任。
我越發感到我孩子的好和他們的幸福,我和他們都沒有經曆過這些。
我不驕縱也不壓製孩子,我希望他們自由自在幸福快樂,但前提是自我約束,尊重他人,不是想要什麽就有什麽的。 從一,兩歲起,我就講道理,即便他們不是很懂。 做錯的地方,盡量不計較,實在需要管教的地方,我給三次機會,並提前告知可能的處罰。第一次隻要認個錯,第二次要彌補過失,第三次要勇敢接受處罰。別忘了說Mommy Love You,讓他們覺得處罰是處罰,你對他們的愛沒有變。處罰要又輕又管用,一般是其中一項:I Will Talk To Your Teacher(基本說說而已), No TV, No Game, No Play Day,No Holiday Gift, 等等(就是失去他們最喜歡的但又不重要的東西)。 不好的行為大多止步於Warning,幾乎到不了處罰這一步,到了我一定實施,說話算數,他們一般也接受得了。 如果他們很傷心,我再提供一項任務,可以得到Reward,把處罰掉的東西又得回來。關鍵是他們Learn The Lesson,不是Feel Sad。
Timeout隻是Take A Break或Calm Down,我一般說Grounded,一年也就兩三次,孩子就傷心的但乖乖的自己回房間去了,根本算不上處罰,但是他們就是感到處罰了。其實我的孩子挺皮的,但不會太過分,更不會不誠實,那是我的底線。 希望我的方法對大家有用。
教育孩子,千萬要弄明白是你在教育孩子。不要變成了孩子在教育你。Time out 本身就是證明你已經黔驢計窮了。因為孩子還小。不懂戰術。稍大點就會明白"哼!我媽(爸)沒招了,隻好處罰我了。"凡走到這樣一步都說明你失敗了。要想孩子聽話,首先要做到你要有明確的"話"。說了不算,算了不說。孩子都不明白你的哪句話要聽,哪句話是說說而已。其次說的"話"要少。孩子小記不住你那麽多的規矩,記不住你那麽多的"不許"規矩多必然犯規也多。你就處罰不過來,不處罰你又成了說話不算數。顧此失彼,還是失敗的結果。女兒把玻璃杯打碎了,她的小朋友嚇壞了:"怎麽辦?""沒事兒,我爸爸從來不為這種事情說我。"因為這不在我的規矩之內。
I laughed so hard when I read your article. It is very struggle for myself to punish my daughter. Girls have way too much drama and tears.
smileymoon 發表評論於
This is how my ex-boss put his daughter timeout -- he drew a small circle on the wall at the same height of her nose. Then he told her to stand facing the wall, stick her nose in the circle and stay still. Very effective. :) He said timeout is a punishment only when the kid can't do anything else but reflects on what he/she has done wrong.