個人資料
正文

UK 政府停止發布無家可歸者死亡數據

(2024-05-31 21:51:22) 下一個

貧困正在摧毀英國

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3zDWAqs9Ybo&ab_channel=reality

2024年5月28日

政府數據顯示,英國無家可歸兒童數量創曆史新高。Newsround 查看了英格蘭、威爾士、蘇格蘭和北愛爾蘭的政府數據,發現英國四分之三的國家中,臨時住所兒童的數量正在增加。

住房慈善機構 Shelter 發現,在英格蘭,2024 年有 145,800 名兒童被記錄為無家可歸者,創曆史新高。這一數字創下了曆史新高,自 2023 年以來增長了 15%。

蘇格蘭的最新數據顯示,有 16,263 名兒童生活在被評估為無家可歸或麵臨無家可歸威脅的家庭中。這比上一年高出 10%,相當於蘇格蘭每天有 45 名兒童無家可歸。

貧困正在扼殺英國

當人們想象無家可歸時,他們往往會想象人們露宿街頭,因物質濫用問題而陷入不安全感。從這個角度來看,人們可能會認為美國在任何國際比較中都會名列前茅。

錯了。無家可歸的主要形式是人們住在臨時住所,主要原因是無力負擔住房,而美國甚至還不是最糟糕的。英國擁有這個可恥的稱號,每 200 個家庭中就有 1 個住在正規住房部門以外的緊急住所,這一數字令人震驚

臨時住所有一定的眼不見心不煩的性質,但它占經合組織無家可歸者的 80% 以上。發達國家有數十萬人過著這種邊緣而脆弱的生活,英國的記錄非常糟糕。

經過幾年的下降,居住在臨時住所的英國家庭數量在 2010 年至 2023 年間從 48,000 戶增加到 112,000 戶,增長了一倍多,創下了有記錄以來的最高水平。我引用英格蘭的數據是因為英格蘭的數據是英國四個國家中最完整的,但其他國家的數據更糟糕。

這些建築的條件通常非常惡劣。潮濕和發黴很常見,昆蟲和動物的侵擾也很常見。從一個地方搬到另一個地方的幹擾導致成年人失業,兒童輟學。僅在過去五年裏,臨時住所的糟糕狀況就被認為是導致英格蘭 55 名兒童死亡的一個因素。

這些安排還給地方議會帶來了巨大的成本,去年地方議會在緊急避難所上花費了近 18 億英鎊,這一數字在過去十年中實際增長了一倍多。

這種噩夢般的情況主要有三個原因:住房建設速度嚴重不足、社會住房部門萎縮以及對無力支付市場租金的人的財政支持減少。

相對於人口規模,英國建造的房屋數量少於絕大多數其他發達國家。這導致私營部門的租金不斷上升,而自 1970 年代以來社會住房部門萎縮了 25%,加劇了這種情況,慢慢關閉了一個至關重要的安全閥。來源:

Poverty is killing the UK

Newsround has looked at government data in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland - and the number of children in temporary accommodation is rising in three out of four UK nations.

Housing charity Shelter has found that in England, a record 145,800 children were recorded as being homeless in 2024 - that is the highest it's ever been.

This has gone up by a record amount - a 15% increase since 2023.

The latest set of figures for Scotland show there were 16,263 children in households that were assessed as homeless or threatened with homelessness.

This is 10% higher than the previous year and is the equivalent to 45 children in Scotland becoming homeless every day.

Poverty is killing the UK
When people picture homelessness, they tend to imagine people sleeping rough on the street, tipped into insecurity by substance use problems. Viewed this way, one might imagine the US would rank highest in any international comparison.

Wrong. The main form of homelessness is people living in temporary accommodation, the main driver is an inability to afford housing, and America is not even particularly close to the worst. The UK holds that ignominious title, with an astonishing one in 200 households living in emergency lodging outside the formal housing sector

There is a certain out of sight, out of mind quality to temporary accommodation, but it accounts for more than 80 per cent of homelessness across the OECD. Hundreds of thousands of people across the developed world live this peripheral and fragile existence, and Britain’s record is dire.

After declining for several years, the number of English households living in temporary accommodation more than doubled between 2010 and 2023 from 48,000 to 112,000, the highest figure since records began. I’m quoting figures for England because it has the most complete data out of the four UK nations, but the others are if anything worse.

Conditions in these buildings are often atrocious. Damp and mould are commonplace, as are insect and animal infestations. The disruption of being moved from place to place causes adults to drop out of work and children out of school. In the past five years alone, the parlous state of temporary accommodation has been cited as a contributing factor in the deaths of 55 children in England.

These arrangements also impose enormous costs on local councils, which last year spent almost £1.8bn on emergency shelter, a figure that has more than doubled in real terms over the past decade.

This nightmare scenario is due to three main factors: woefully inadequate rates of housebuilding, a dwindling social housing sector and the erosion of financial support for those unable to afford market rents.

Relative to population size, the UK builds fewer homes than the vast majority of other developed countries. This has sent private sector rents spiralling, exacerbated by a 25 per cent shrinking of the social housing sector since the 1970s, slowly closing a crucial safety valve.  sources:

https://trustforlondon.org.uk/news/wh... https://theconversation.com/the-uk-go... https://www.ft.com/content/24117a03-3... https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/68574869

Record number of children affected by homelessness in the UK

https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/68574869

Figures from the government show there are record numbers of children in the UK who are affected by homelessness.

Newsround has looked at government data in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland - and the number of children in temporary accommodation is rising in three out of four UK nations.

Housing charity Shelter has found that in England, a record 145,800 children were recorded as being homeless in 2024 - that is the highest it's ever been.

This has gone up by a record amount - a 15% increase since 2023.

The latest set of figures for Scotland show there were 16,263 children in households that were assessed as homeless or threatened with homelessness.

This is 10% higher than the previous year and is the equivalent to 45 children in Scotland becoming homeless every day.

Newsround have been investigating the impact of homelessness on children in our special programme No Place to Call Home.

The statistics in Northern Ireland show that in July 2023, just under 4,600 children were living in temporary accommodation.

Around 3,000 of these children were aged nine and under, which has gone up by 88% since 2019.

Data in Wales is collected month by month. The latest figures released in January 2024, show 411 children under the age of 16 were put into temporary accommodation.

英國政府計劃停止發布無家可歸者死亡統計數據——這就是為什麽這是一個問題

https://theconversation.com/the-uk-government-aims-to-stop-publishing-stats-on-homeless-peoples-deaths-heres-why-thats-a-problem-223879

2024 年 2 月 22 日

Daniel McCulloch
開放大學犯罪學和社會政策講師

Victoria Cooper
開放大學社會政策和犯罪學講師

合作夥伴
開放大學作為 The Conversation UK 的創始合作夥伴提供資金。查看所有合作夥伴

英國政府正在就停止發布國家統計局 (ONS) 關於無家可歸者死亡的重要統計數據的計劃進行磋商。這是對死亡率統計數據進行更廣泛審查的一部分,包括養老院死亡和冬季死亡。

自 2018 年以來,英格蘭和威爾士的國家統計局和蘇格蘭國家檔案館 (NRS) 每年都會發布關於無家可歸者死亡情況的報告。這些數據提供了記錄的死亡人數逐年變化的見解,包括有關性別、年齡和死因的詳細信息。(有計劃在北愛爾蘭整理類似的官方數據,但尚未公布。)

英國政府聲稱這些統計數據是“實驗性的”,需要“進一步開發工作”才能使其達到“國家統計數據水平”。作為谘詢的一部分,政府正在尋求對這些統計數據“相對重要性”的反饋,谘詢將於 2024 年 3 月 5 日結束。

我們的研究表明,死亡對無家可歸的人來說是一個持續的威脅。然而,公眾或政客很少認為這是無家可歸困境的一部分。

閱讀基於證據而非恐慌的新聞報道。

穿著藍色高能見度背心的人坐在桌子上,桌上放著食物。誌願者向無家可歸的人分發食物。 Shutterstock
生死中無形的事物
在全球範圍內,無家可歸者的死亡率是普通人群的三到四倍。無家可歸和健康專家 James J. O’Connell 表示,盡管世界各地不同機構衡量無家可歸相關死亡率的方法各不相同,但國際死亡率卻“驚人地一致”——“跨越國界、文化和海洋”。

研究表明,無家可歸的成年人和兒童比普通人群更容易患上潛在健康問題。無家可歸者因暴力事故死亡的可能性更大,例如被機動車碾壓或被垃圾車壓死。

直到 2018 年,英國政府才開始追蹤無家可歸者死亡的人數。隻有當調查新聞局和記者 Maeve McClenaghan 與位於倫敦的無家可歸者博物館合作,在他們的“無家可歸者死亡”項目中揭示了這一問題的深層隱蔽性時,英格蘭和威爾士的國家統計局和國家統計局才開始著手解決這一問題。

到目前為止,他們的數據是英國無家可歸相關死亡的最準確的官方數據。然而,它並不完美——國家統計局承認這一點,並建議謹慎解讀。

這些數據限製包括驗屍官報告的不可靠性,這些報告並不總是記錄死者無家可歸的事實。這可能是由於向登記員提供的信息不完整,或者出於對死者家人的考慮。

死亡證明上也沒有具體問題詢問一個人在死亡時是否無家可歸。相反,國家統計局必須在死亡證明數據中搜索指定為“無固定住所”或已知旅館的注冊地址。而且,國家統計局還沒有一份完整的無家可歸者宿舍和緊急避難所名單,盡管這樣的名單目前正在製定中。

磚砌通道下的橙色帳篷。無家可歸的人在生死中都遭受著隱形。Shutterstock

為什麽這很重要
缺乏有關無家可歸人口的數據並不是一個新現象。它強調了無家可歸者遭受的更廣泛的隱形。

露宿街頭的人數統計方法並不完善。2022 年,英格蘭 80% 的地方當局使用“基於證據的估計會議”來衡量露宿街頭者的數量。這涉及當地機構(例如慈善機構、外展團隊和無家可歸者住宿服務)對一個典型夜晚可能有多少人露宿街頭做出明智的估計。隻有 20% 的地方當局真正統計了他們看到的露宿街頭的人數。

當然,無家可歸不僅僅包括露宿街頭。法定無家可歸者是指地方當局負有主要責任的人

住房或救濟職責,他們與申請人合作,試圖防止或緩解無家可歸的情況(例如,製定個性化計劃來支持申請人)。

研究表明,用於衡量和評估無家可歸和露宿街頭的工具大大低估了無家可歸的程度。沒有資格獲得法定支持的人不計算在內。

此外,並非所有無家可歸者都會向地方當局自首,因為有些人(通常被稱為“隱藏的無家可歸者”)因害怕被拒絕而推遲申請。由於法定無家可歸的數據是根據這些申請匯編的,許多無家可歸的成年人和兒童被排除在官方統計數據之外。

健康研究人員認為,無家可歸是一場公共衛生危機。衡量其嚴重程度——通過發布無家可歸期間死亡人數的官方統計數據——是應對這一問題的第一步。

在驅逐率不斷上升、經濟適用房建設係統即將崩潰的時候,無家可歸者的死亡是一個關鍵的政治問題。英國政府需要為此承擔責任。

The UK government aims to stop publishing stats on homeless people's deaths – here's why that's a problem

https://theconversation.com/the-uk-government-aims-to-stop-publishing-stats-on-homeless-peoples-deaths-heres-why-thats-a-problem-223879?

Disclosure statement

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Partners

The Open University provides funding as a founding partner of The Conversation UK.  View all partners

CC BY ND
We believe in the free flow of information
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence.

The UK government is consulting on plans to stop publishing vital statistics from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) on deaths of homeless people. This is part of a wider review of mortality statistics including deaths in care homes and winter mortality.

Since 2018, the ONS in England and Wales and the National Records for Scotland (NRS) have published annual reports about the deaths of homeless people. This data offers insights into year-on-year changes in recorded deaths, including details about sex, age and cause of death. (There are plans to collate similar official data in Northern Ireland, but none has yet been published.)

The UK government claims that these statistics are “experimental” and that “further development work” is needed to bring them up to “national statistics status”. As part of its consultation, which closes on March 5 2024, the government is looking for feedback on “the relative importance” of these statistics.

Our research shows that death is a constant threat for people experiencing homelessness. However, this is rarely considered, by the public or by politicians, as part of the plight of being unhoused.

Read news coverage based on evidence, not alarm.
People in blue high-vis vests at a table with food for distribution.Volunteers distribute food to homeless people. Shutterstock

Invisible in life and death

Globally, homeless populations are three-to-four times more likely to die than the general population. Homelessness and health expert James J. O’Connell has said that despite the diverse methodologies different institutions across the world use to measure homelessness-related mortality, there is a “remarkable consistency” in death rates internationally – one that “transcends borders, cultures and oceans”.

Research shows that homeless adults and children are more likely to suffer underlying health conditions than the general population. Unhoused people are disproportionately likely to die due to violent accidents, such as being run over by a motor vehicle, or being crushed in a bin lorry.

Until 2018, the UK government did not track the number of people dying while homeless. Only when the Bureau of Investigative Journalism and journalist Maeve McClenaghan, working with London-based group The Museum of Homelessness, revealed the profound invisibility of this precise issue as part of their Dying Homeless project, did the ONS in England and Wales and the NRS begin to tackle it.

To date, their data is the most accurate official data on homelessness-related deaths in the UK. It is, however, imperfect – the ONS recognises as much, and advises caution in how it is interpreted.

These data limitations include the unreliability of coroners’ reports, which do not always record the fact that the deceased was homeless. This might be due to incomplete information given to the registrar, or out of consideration for the person’s family.

There is also no specific question on a death certificate to ask if a person was homeless at the time of death. Instead, the ONS must search death certificate data for registered addresses specified as “no fixed abode” or that are of a known hostel. And the ONS does not yet have a comprehensive list of all homeless hostels and emergency shelters, although such a list is now in development.

An orange tent under a brick passageway.Unhoused people suffer from invisibility in both life and death. Shutterstock

Why this matters

The absence of data concerning homeless populations is not a new phenomenon. It underlines the wider invisibility from which unhoused people suffer.

The way people sleeping rough are counted involves less-than-perfect methods. In 2022, 80% of local authorities in England gauged numbers of rough sleepers using an “evidence-based estimate meeting”. This involves local agencies (such as charities, outreach teams and homelessness accommodation services) giving an informed estimate of how many people might be sleeping rough on a typical night. Only 20% of local authorities actually counted the people they saw sleeping rough.

And of course, homelessness covers more than rough sleeping. Statutory homelessness refers to people to whom local authorities owe either a main duty to house or a relief duty, whereby they work with applicants to attempt to prevent or relieve homelessness (for example, by developing a personalised plan to support an applicant).

Research shows the tools used to measure and assess homelessness and rough sleeping vastly underestimate how extensive it is. People who are not eligible for statutory support are not counted.

Further, not all homeless people will present themselves to local authorities, as some people – often referred to as the “hidden homeless” – are put off from applying because of fears of being rejected. As data on statutory homelessness is compiled based on these applications, many homeless adults and children are excluded from official statistics.

Health researchers argue that homelessness presents a public health crisis. Gauging the extent of it – by publishing official statistics on the number of people who die while homeless – is the first step in combating it.

At a time when evictions are rising and the affordable housebuilding system is set to all but collapse, deaths of homeless people is a critical political issue. The UK government needs to take responsibility for it.

Before you go…

If you found the article you just read to be insightful, you’ll be interested in our free daily newsletter. It’s filled with the insights of academic experts, written so that everyone can understand what’s going on in the world. Each newsletter has articles that will inform and intrigue you.

 Scott White; CEO | Editor-in-Chief
[ 打印 ]
閱讀 ()評論 (0)
評論
目前還沒有任何評論
登錄後才可評論.