這些實驗對象還都是肥胖有病的人,叫他們吃低碳高脂飲食(50%的熱量來自飽和脂肪,很高脂),結果是血脂都減低了。
Abstract
OBJECTIVE:
To determine whether a diet of high saturated fat and avoidance of starch (HSF-SA) results in weight loss without adverse effects on serum lipids in obese nondiabetic patients.
PATIENTS AND METHODS:
Twenty-three patients with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease participated in a prospective 6-week trial at the Christiana Care Medical Center in Newark, Del, between August 2000 and September 2001. All patients were obese (mean +/- SD body mass index [BMI], 39.0+/-7.3 kg/m2) and had been treated with statins before entry in the trial. Fifteen obese patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (BMI, 36.1+/-9.7 kg/m2) and 8 obese patients with reactive hypoglycemia (BMI, 46.8+/-10 kg/m2) were monitored during an HSF-SA diet for 24 and 52 weeks, respectively, between 1997 and 2000.
RESULTS:
In patients with atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, mean +/- SD total body weight (TBW) decreased 5.2%+/-2.5% (P<.001 as did body fat percentage nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic analysis of lipids showed decreases in total triglycerides very low-density lipoprotein vldl size large concentration and medium high-density ldl concentrations were unchanged but hdl increased. patients with polycystic ovary syndrome lost tbw reactive hypoglycemia at weeks respectively without adverse effects on serum lipids.>
CONCLUSION:
An HSF-SA diet results in weight loss after 6 weeks without adverse effects on serum lipid levels verified by nuclear magnetic resonance, and further weight loss with a lipid-neutral effect may persist for up to 52 weeks.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14601690
不是借此提倡每個人都吃高脂肪,而是覺得,人體營養學有很多誤區和未知未定論的東西。
教授:看看這個早已經做了的實驗,對象不是老鼠,雞,兔子,是大活人
所有跟帖:
•
謝謝分享。這個研究樣本太小,時間也短,效果也不算特別明顯。還引起其LDL,HDL,TG指標的變壞,對此很有保留,有評論如下,
-吃與活-
♂
(1108 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
11:52:57
•
Re "還引起其LDL,HDL,TG指標的變壞"
-Lily168-
♀
(853 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
12:28:20
•
對不起,你是對的,後麵是說另外一個類似的diet的,不是這個實驗。
-吃與活-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
12:42:29
•
謝謝教授的回複和個人體驗的無私分享。你對老周的介紹也讓我對油脂碳水的作用再思考。
-Lily168-
♀
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
12:48:44
•
你逼著我又稍微仔細的看了一遍原文:)我不是做這類實驗的行家,但我覺得這個實驗確實說服力有限。
-吃與活-
♂
(661 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
13:28:05
•
說的有道理。
-Lily168-
♀
(241 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
14:23:45
•
但病人可能不習慣吃這種飲食,吃的就少。如果不是卡路裏攝取下降,病人又沒有增加鍛煉消耗卡路裏,減肥是不可能的。
-吃與活-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
14:50:10
•
你的前提是,a calorie is a calorie
-Lily168-
♀
(352 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
15:23:54
•
周末愉快!有空請說說為什麽不大同意這個前提,我覺得可能很有意思。
-吃與活-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
20:24:16
•
這個我相信是你的看法。前麵那個是Gau的看法,不是你的。
-Lily168-
♀
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
14:38:46
•
想偷懶,被抓,隻好自己看:)
-吃與活-
♂
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
14:52:17
•
啊啊 這麽多的評論要回複...忙
-Lily168-
♀
(0 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
15:08:26
•
6周的飲食改變,引起的效果維持了52周,“效果也不算特別明顯”?你當然可以保留你的意見。
-Lily168-
♀
(21 bytes)
()
09/05/2014 postreply
12:32:55