風蕭蕭_Frank
以文會友
我的朋友第一次嚐試了中國的地鐵
YouTube 哈維在中國 2023年8月24日
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nk8ffqFXx8k&ab_channel=
在這個視頻中，我的朋友瑞恩對中國大陸與日本和台灣省的對比發表了他的看法。
瑞恩過去一年一直住在台灣，現在已經在中國大陸住了一個星期。瑞恩將在可預見的未來在上海工作，之前沒有中國大陸的經曆，所以請告訴我你希望我們一起做什麽樣的視頻！
415 條評論
@Taiwan_Prospers_with_China 9個月前
作為一個住在台北的人，你說對了。對年輕人的宣傳簡直令人作嘔。
11 條回複
@weizhang28349個月前
這是美國和日本在台灣媒體上的錢
@liveintc 9個月前
你說得太對了。
@ninersnation3298 9個月前
中國應該繼續給台灣人發中國身份證，這樣所有台灣人都可以像本地中國人一樣享受所有福利。這樣，就會促使更多的台灣人訪問中國大陸。你想讓台灣人來大陸感受現代、財富等的驕傲。
@44jwong 9個月前
我想很多人不會/不能獨立思考。
@user-di4jx7me7d 9個月前
?@ninersnation3298 我是中國人，我的英語不好，我用穀歌翻譯。我認識在中國大陸的台灣人，有些福利甚至比當地人還好。台灣當局和美國勾結阻止台灣回歸才是問題所在。
@Elfan97-ec1uk 9個月前
他們竟然如此無恥，竟然否認自己和年輕一代的曆史、身份和血統！
@loadingnewads9個月前
然而事實上我在國內完全沒有意識到那些宣傳的存在，早看膩了，目前看來隻是對外國人有效了。
@wilsonlee5590 8個月前
一些批評中國的人說，政府控製著媒體和新聞。然而，台灣對涉及中國的新聞和媒體的限製似乎實際上更為嚴格。這會導致台灣民眾產生誤解，有些人甚至試圖讓人們仇恨中國。
一個簡單的問題：你相信一個有問題的政府和文化能夠讓一個國家發展得很好嗎？
@christinalin5658 8個月前
@ninersnation3298 中國確實向台灣人發放了身份證。
@baobaolove2801 8個月前
人無完人！沒有一個國家是完美的！沒有一個政治製度是完美的！管好自己的事兒就能幫助別人！你不是神！！！
@ChinaSongsCollection 9個月前
嗨。喜歡你的視頻。我是出生在香港但在西方長大的華裔。
我認為自己非常支持中國。但情況並非一直如此。我之所以變得非常支持中國，是因為西方媒體對中國進行了無休止的極其惡劣的惡意宣傳。我相信有很多像我一樣的海外華人，一開始並不支持中國，但因為西方媒體和相信媒體的人而堅定地支持中國。
@laraw840 9個月前（修改過）
台灣年輕人的反華情緒很大程度上源於學校教育體係和媒體。在教育方麵，自2012年主張獨立的民進黨上台執政以來，它從初中開始就取消並簡化了教科書中的中國曆史內容（在此之前，像我這樣的學生已經學習了全麵而詳細的5000年前的中國朝代）。他們還將中國曆史移到了課程的世界曆史部分；開始將中華人民共和國稱為中國，而不是使用島上大約半個世紀以來常用的“大陸”一詞。這些都是民進黨精心策劃的疏遠台灣青年與中國的一些例子。在媒體方麵，民進黨的宣傳無處不在，在學校、新聞和社交媒體上都有出現……幾年前，他們甚至關閉了中天新聞，因為它被認為“過於親中”。我是台灣人，就我個人而言，我不想與民進黨有任何聯係。我可以尊重他們希望台灣成為一個獨立國家的願望，但他們這樣做的方式顯然是卑鄙和不民主的。當然，台灣媒體的敘述也深受西方主流媒體的影響，隨著社交媒體的興起和全球獨立媒體的湧現，我希望更多的人能夠意識到這些敘述是多麽的偏頗，往往充斥著扭曲和隱藏的議程，尤其是針對中國。
@samyang5873 9個月前（修改過）
我是東南亞人。美國的足跡遍布世界各地，總是幹涉主權國家的內政，考慮到她遠在大洋彼岸，這是非常不受歡迎和令人厭惡的。至於台灣，它在法律上和官方上被包括美國在內的聯合國承認為中國的一部分。但美國喜歡說一套做一套。我既不住在中國也不住在台灣，但看看美國在這一地區正在采取的行動，如果不小心，台灣可能會都落入陷阱，最終落得烏克蘭的下場。這將影響整個亞洲的穩定與和平。考慮到美國長期的戰爭曆史和為霸權而發動的對外侵略，美國確實不是一個和平的國家，將其他國家推向流血。台灣和中國的問題是中國的事情，美國和西方不應該插手。中國強調和平統一，但美國會告訴台灣人購買越來越多的武器。中國建設基礎設施和一帶一路，而美國一直在建設軍事基地和出售武器。誰是真正的威脅？
@yonight6871 9個月前（修改過）
2019年我去紐約度假，2020年去邁阿密度假。我對美國糟糕的公共交通感到驚訝。尤其是在紐約，在我了解了大多數歐洲城市的地鐵之後，地鐵對我來說似乎是最糟糕的。美國公共基礎設施的衰落狀況令人驚訝。我也認為高速公路非常糟糕。狀況非常糟糕。
我去過中國四次，參觀了不同的地區。每次我去中國，都會看到很大的改善。我甚至可以大膽地說，中國的主要城市現在看起來比美國的主要城市更幹淨。
例如，我去過大連的公園，驚訝於它們看起來有多幹淨。城市的綠化非常好，街上有很多電動車，這證明中國政府非常重視環境保護。給我印象最深的是生活非常方便，是一個無現金社會，地鐵係統非常新、幹淨，人們非常友好。除了一些文化衝擊外，我覺得中國非常安全。你也可以在深夜外出。在美國，我不敢在晚上外出，因為擔心黑人會開槍打我。
當我回到家，告訴我的同事我在中國旅行的事時，他們拒絕相信我或我拍的照片。他們隻想相信我參觀了一個為遊客而建的“假城市”。我獨自在這些城市裏行走的事實……仍然不會改變他們的信念。不，這些人仍然想相信中國有“落後的霧霾城市，那裏的每個人都仍然騎自行車，穿著灰色的舊衣服，因為他們都很窮，都在挨餓”。我經常聽到無知的言論，例如：“最窮的美國人仍然比普通中國人生活得好”。諷刺的是，這些人從未去過中國，甚至不想看這些視頻。
然而……這些人說話都像“中國專家”。無論如何，在中國玩得開心，上帝保佑
@sktan3743 9個月前
如果台灣年輕人像井底之蛙一樣望著天空，那麽台灣的處境就很可悲了，尤其是他們為了追求所謂的自由而要求獨立。最終他們必須麵對現實。過去30年台灣的經濟繁榮建立在對華貿易的巨大貿易順差之上。這一順差抵消了與包括日本在內的所有其他國家的貿易逆差。可以說，這一順差使台灣能夠購買美國武器來對抗中國。沒有什麽比恩人恩將仇報更瘋狂的了。
@redbelief 9個月前
台灣從來就不是一個國家。1949年，前國民黨政府中華民國在與共產黨政府的內戰中失敗，逃往中國領土的最南端。即使在1949年新中國成立後，台灣也不得不解放，但不幸的是，朝鮮戰爭在1949年爆發。 1950年，美國戰機飛抵中國邊境，轟炸丹東等邊境城市。中國政府向朝鮮半島增派軍隊，保衛國家，對抗美國。朝鮮戰爭後的三年，中國遭受了嚴重的自然災害和磨難，由於文革等複雜的國內形勢，台灣的解放再次被推遲。由於80年代改革開放後中國專注於經濟發展，台灣的解放再次被推遲。然而，世界從未承認台灣是一個國家，世界上大多數國家都沒有與台灣建立外交關係。1971年，中華民國被驅逐出聯合國，聯合國會員國一致承認中華人民共和國是代表中國的唯一合法政府，聯合國決議宣布台灣是中華人民共和國領土的一部分
@oceejekwam6829 9個月前
你們的vlog給人一種非常真實的感覺。謝謝你們兩個。
@Mal17281 8個月前
我剛從中國回來。我們去了重慶、成都和西安。我隻能說，那裏的人非常友好，機場的警察幫我們將酒店的名字從英文翻譯成了中文，方便我們的出租車司機。每個人都很樂於助人，因為我們不會說中文。地鐵很幹淨。我不能談論他們的政府，因為我不住在但這裏的人確實很棒。最棒的是這裏非常安全。
下麵是英文原文
My Friend Tried The Subway in China (First Time)
Harvey in China
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nk8ffqFXx8k&ab_channel=HarveyinChina
2023年8月24日 CHINA
In this video my friend Ryan gives his first thoughts on mainland China vs Japan & the province of Taiwan after living here for one week.
Ryan has been living in Taiwan for the past year, and has lived in mainland China for one week now. Ryan will be working in Shanghai for the foreseeable future, and has no previous experience of Mainland China, so let me know what kind of videos you'd like to see us do together!
415 條評論
@Taiwan_Prospers_with_China 9個月前
As someone living in Taipei, you hit it right on the nail. The propaganda towards the youth is plain disgusting.
11 條回複
@weizhang28349個月前
This is America and japan money in Taiwan medias
@liveintc 9個月前
You are so right.
@ninersnation3298 9個月前
China should just go ahead issue taiwanese a chinese id card so all those taiwanese enjoy all the benefits as any local chinese. This way, it will promote more taiwanese to visit mainland china. you want taiwanese to come to mainland to feel the pride of modern, wealth, etc.
@44jwong 9個月前
I suppose a lot don't / can't think for themselves.
@user-di4jx7me7d 9個月前
? @ninersnation3298 I am Chinese, my English is not good, I use Google Translate. The Taiwanese I know have all these in mainland China, and some benefits are even better than the locals. The collusion between the Taiwan authorities and the United States to prevent Taiwan's return is the problem.
@Elfan97-ec1uk 9個月前
So shameless to deny themselves n their younger generation of their own history, identity n ancestry!
@loadingnewads9個月前
然而事實上我在國內完全就沒有意識到那些宣傳的存在，早看膩了，目前看來隻對外國人有效了。
@wilsonlee5590 8個月前
Some people who are critical of China say that the government controls the media and news. However, it seems that Taiwan is actually more restrictive of news and media related to China. This can lead to misunderstandings among the people from Taiwan, and some even try to make people hate China.
A simple question: Do you believe that a problematic government and culture can develop a country well?
@christinalin5658 8個月前
@ninersnation3298 China does issue ID cards to Taiwanese.
@baobaolove2801 8個月前
Nobody is perfect! No country is perfect! No political system is perfect! Mind your own business well and you can help others! Yu are not God!!!
@ChinaSongsCollection
9個月前
Hi. Like your video。I'm ethnic Chinese born in Hong Kong but brought up in the West.
I consider myself very pro- China. But it hasn't always been like this.I've become very pro- China because of all these extremely nasty non-stop malicious propaganda against China in the Western media.
I'm sure there are a lot of overseas Chinese like myself who weren't pro- China to start off with, but became staunchly pro- China because of the Western media and the people believing the media.
@laraw840 9個月前（修改過）
The anti-China sentiments among the youth in Taiwan largely stem from the school education system and media. In terms of education, ever since the DPP, the pro-independent party - stepped up as the ruling party back in 2012, it eliminated and simplified the Chinese history content in the textbooks from junior high school onwards (Prior to that, students like myself have studied comprehensive and detailed Chinese dynasties dating back 5,000 years). They also moved Chinese history into the World History section of the curriculum; began referring to the PRC as China, as opposed to using the term 'the Mainland' which had been commonly used for about half a century on the island. These are some of the examples of DPP's calculated moves to distance Taiwanese youth from China. In terms of media, DPP's propaganda is pervasive, present at school, in the news, and on social media...etc. A few years ago, they even shut down CTI news because it was deemed "too pro-China". I am Taiwanese, and personally, I do not want to be associated with DPP on any level. I can respect their desire for Taiwan to be an independent country, but the way they go about doing it is plain nasty and undemocratic. Of course, Taiwan's media narratives are deeply influenced by Western mainstream media as well, which, with the rise of social media and sprouting independent media worldwide, I hope more people will come to realize how those narratives can be extremely biased, oftentimes rife with distortion and hidden agendas, especially and particularly toward China.
@samyang5873 9個月前（修改過）
I'm SEAsian. US has her footprints all over the world & always meddling in internal affairs of sovereign countries which is very unwelcome & disgusting considering that she is oceans away. As for Taiwan , it is legally & officially recognised as part of China by the United Nation including the US. But the US likes to say one thing and do another. I neither live in China nor Taiwan but looking at what the US ongoing actions in this part of the world , if not careful Taiwan might fall into the trap & ends up like Ukraine. This will affect stability & peace in whole of Asia. US is indeed not a peaceful country considering her long history of wars & foreign aggression for the sake of hegemony by pushing others to bloodshed. The issue of Taiwan & China is a Chinese affair & US & the west should stay out of it. China stressed a peaceful unification but US would tell the Taiwanese to buy more & more weapons. China builds infrastructures & BRI & US is always building military bases & selling arms. Who's the real threat ??
@yonight6871
9個月前（修改過）
In 2019 I went on vacation to NY and in 2020 to Miami. And I was surprised by how bad public transport is in the USA. Especially in NY, the subway seemed to me the worst after knowing the one in most European cities. The state of decline of public infrastructures in the USA is surprising. I also thought the highways were very bad. In very bad condition.
I've visited China four times and saw different regions. Every time I've visited... I've seen big improvements. I would even be bold enough to say that the major cities in China are now overall cleaner looking than the major cities in the US.
For one example, I've visited public parks in Dalian and was amazed at how clean they look. The greening of the city is very good, and there are many electric cars on the street, which proves that the Chinese government attaches great importance to environmental protection.What impresses me the most is that life is very convenient, a cashless society, the subway system is very new and clean, and the people are very friendly.Other than some culture shock, I feel China is very safe. You can also go out late at night. In the US, I dare not go out at night, for fear that black people will shoot me.
When I return home and tell my co-workers about my travels to China.... they refuse to believe me or the pictures I took. They just want to believe that I was shown around a "fake city" built for showing tourists. The fact that I was walking around these cities unescorted... still won't change their beliefs. No, these people still want to believe that China has "backward smoggy cities, where everyone still rides bicycles and wear grey old clothes because they are all poor and starving". I often hear ignorant statements such as: "The poorest Americans still live better than the average Chinese". The irony is these people never traveled to China or even want to watch these videos.
And yet... these folks talk like they are all "China experts'. Anyway, have fun in China and God b
@sktan3743 9個月前
If young Taiwanese are looking at the sky like frogs in a well, then it is a very sorry state for Taiwan, especially they clamor for independence in pursuits of so called freedom. Eventually they have to face up to reality. Taiwan economic prosperity for past 3 decades are built on enormous trade surplus from China trade. This surplus cancels the trade deficits with all other countries including Japan.This surplus enables Taiwan to buy American weaponry with which to fight China, so to speak. Nothing is more insane for anyone to bite the hands that feed him.
@redbelief
9個月前
Taiwan has never been a country. In 1949, the former Kuomintang government, the Republic of China, was defeated in a civil war against the Communist government and fled to the southernmost tip of Chinese territory. Even after the founding of New China in 1949, Taiwan had to be liberated, but unfortunately, the Korean War broke out in 1950, and American fighter jets flew to the Chinese border and dropped bombs on border cities such as Dandong. The Chinese government sent reinforcements to the Korean Peninsula to protect the country and confront the United States. During the three years following the Korean War, severe natural disasters and adversity befell China, and Taiwan's liberation was delayed again due to complex domestic situations such as the Cultural Revolution. As China focused on economic development after reform and opening in the 1980s, Taiwan's liberation was delayed again. However, the world has never recognized Taiwan as a country, and most countries in the world have not established diplomatic ties with Taiwan. In 1971, the Republic of China was expelled from the United Nations, UN member states consistently recognized the People's Republic of China as the only legitimate government representing China, and a United Nations resolution declared Taiwan part of the territory of the People's Republic of China
@oceejekwam6829 9個月前
A very authentic feel comes across in your vlogs. Thank you to both of you.
@Mal17281 8個月前
I just came back from China. We went to Chongqing, Chengdu and Xian. All I can say is that people are extremely friendly, the policeman at the airport helped us translated our hotel name from English to Chinese for our taxi driver. Everyone was very helpful since we do not speak Chinese. Subway is so cleaned. I can’t speak about their government since I don’t live there but the people are definitely amazing. Best of all, it is so safe.
