同意/不同意她的一個觀點。

1。就valley of ashes，她說'I honestly don't know what Fitzgerald is talking about', 'who are those men (ash grey men)'? etc.
I agree. I don't know what Fitzgerald is talking about either.
2。就一輛limousine的driver和passengers的那一段， 她說'This really is a completely unnecessary detail'.
I disagree. 我們不能用現代的眼光來取舍非現代文學作品的內容。我們要以當時的曆史背景來分析理解一個作品。

所有跟帖： 

• I agree with her.that details sounds grotesque -sportwoman- ♀ (429 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 09:29:18

• my 1.5cents only,welcome to throw me back with American dollars -sportwoman- ♀ (203 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 09:53:24

• I am a poor scholar, destitute of a dollar -onceuponatime- ♀ (101 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 13:14:06

• ahem...there is a tickle in my throat... -sportwoman- ♀ (232 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 14:19:22

• If Fitzgerald were alive and writing the novel today -onceuponatime- ♀ (436 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 12:27:29

• TO BE HONEST,this is the second English book that I could read -sportwoman- ♀ (1805 bytes) () 10/06/2012 postreply 14:09:36