在Farewell to Alms這本書裏(http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688541.html),Gregory Clark博士指出,近代英國超過中國和印度要歸功於600-800年期間英國上流社會的高生育率。由於上流社會十幾代人的高生育率,英國民族的平均智商得到大大的提高。Clark博士認為工業革命始於英國的根源是英國人的分析智商高於中國人和印度人。出生率和智商數據也證實了他的分析。
在 Understanding Human History 一書中(http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688542.html),Michael Hart 博士指出:猶太人本來智商一般,但通過優良選種政策,經過數千年,他們目前在智商競賽中遠遠超前於其它民族。http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688543.html
回複mikecwu的評論:
請參照Dr. Richard Lynn 2002年的文章:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_and_the_Wealth_of_Nations
摘抄其中的一段:
For People's Republic of China, the authors used a figure of 109.4 for Shanghai and adjusted it down by an arbitrary 6 points because they believed the average across China's rural areas was probably less than that in Shanghai. Another figure from a study done in Beijing was not adjusted downwards. Those two studies formed the resultant score for China (PRC).
1.上海的平均IQ是109.4,甚至高於香港新加坡
2.Dr. Richard Lynn已經考慮到中國rural area IQ低於上海的可能性,所以取值的時候,減掉了6點
3.綜合以上兩點,你的關於“中國智商指數隻是城市人智商指數,不是全國指數”的指責不成立
4.考慮猶太人的智商,是考慮所有猶太人的平均智商,而不是某些猶太人的智商,比如如Ashkenazi Jews。用智商最高的猶太人智商與被中國平均智商相比,不公平
從你的帖子中摘抄:
1 Chinese score well on the visual-spatial half of IQ tests (higher than Jews)
2 It's the Ashkenazi Jews who average the world #1 verbal-analytical IQs
得到的結論,中國人visual-spatial高於猶太人(理解為所有的猶太人,包括Ashkenazi Jews),Ashkenazi Jews verbal-analytical高於中國人,換句話說,非Ashkenazi Jews verbal-analytical不高於中國人,Ashkenazi Jews和非Ashkenazi Jews IQ按人口一平均,猶太人平均verbal-analytical IQ不一定高於中國人. visual-spatial和verbal-analytical相加,得不到猶太人智商高於中國人的結論
"And Chinese are failing the reality test of survival"
--這可是你自己一個人的看法,不代表是事實.事實是華人有很強的生存能力.例子我就不舉了,你自己去找吧.你的這個觀點更證明你對華人有強烈的偏見,已經到了無視事實的地步,你自己去反省吧
1. Israel includes lots of not-too-smart Sephardic Jews, Mizrahi Jews, and 85-IQ Arabs. Also, the smartest Ashkenazi Jews live outside of Israel (e.g. U.S., U.K.)
2. The question of Verbal-analytical IQ v. Visual-spatial IQ:
Chinese score well on the visual-spatial half of IQ tests (higher than Jews), but the half that really matters is verbal-analytical IQ (as mentioned in that article, in invention, in organization, etc.)
3. It's the Ashkenazi Jews who average the world #1 verbal-analytical IQs, far above English, Germans, Japanese, or Chinese.
It's dangerous to assume Chinese have infinite brainpower to kill off when results in science and corporation don't show it.
And Chinese are failing the reality test of survival. Even with the "talent" that we have - an amount set to diminish - we're getting wiped out.
That illusion of infinite talent, plus infinite people is another excuse for most Chinese to do nothing. For example, one of my Overseas Chinese friends back in N.Y.C., born in Shanghai without any siblings due to the 1-child policy, not a dumb guy, lazily assumes we're too many to ever get wiped out.
關鍵數據摘抄:
Country/Region↓ IQ (2006)[1]↓
Hong Kong 108
Singapore 108
North Korea 106*
South Korea 106
Japan 105
Taiwan 105
China 105
Italy 102
Iceland 101
Mongolia 101*
Switzerland 101
Netherlands 100
Norway 100
United Kingdom 100
Germany 99
Finland 99
Israel 95
在Farewell to Alms這本書裏(http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688541.html),Gregory Clark博士指出,近代英國超過中國和印度要歸功於600-800年期間英國上流社會的高生育率。由於上流社會十幾代人的高生育率,英國民族的平均智商得到大大的提高。Clark博士認為工業革命始於英國的根源是英國人的分析智商高於中國人和印度人。出生率和智商數據也證實了他的分析。
在 Understanding Human History 一書中(http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688542.html),Michael Hart 博士指出:猶太人本來智商一般,但通過優良選種政策,經過數千年,他們目前在智商競賽中遠遠超前於其它民族。http://www.pinggu.org/bbs/a-688543.html