NSC EB1b收到RFE求助

今天收到NSC EB1b申請的RFE，７月２日前必須回複。請大家幫忙看看需要準備些什麽材料。我想推薦信，更新過的引用列表（這個沒有多少，比較弱），新的評審信是必需的。但怎樣argue RFE的要求比較沒底。請大家幫忙，多謝。另外，似乎IO是 EX0653，有人也是這個IO的RFE嗎？

**The petitioner claims that the beneficiary has made original scientific or scholarly research contributions to the academic field; however, the evidence submitted with the petition is insufficient to establish that the research of the beneficiary has had an impact in the field. Therefore, please submit documentary evidence to show that the beneficiary's original
scientific or scholarly research have contributed to the field.

The petitioner submits several letters from individuals making
recommendations on behalf of the beneficiary; however, while several of the letters express that the beneficiary's work with the *** algorithm along with other research is groundbreading, none of the letters are supported by documentary evidence establishing that the benefinciary's research has indeed been used to make an original contribution to the field. Therefore,
please submit documentary evidence to establish such finding.

** Also, the petitioner indicates that the beneficiary's research work has been used by others to further research in the academic field. However, after review it does not appear that the beneficiary's work has risen to the level of outstanding in the field. Please submit documentary evidence to show that others in the field find the beneficiary's work to be outstanding and are using it to further research.

** It is achnowledged that the petitioner submitted evidence to establish that the beneficiary has participated either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied academic field. Please submit documentary evidence to establish that it is outstanding relative to others who participate in the peer-review process

** It is noted that the beneficiary has published articles; however, this docs not appear to be an extraordinary number of articles. Please provide evidence of any other scholarly book, book chapters or articles that the beneficiary may have authored or co-authored prior to the filing date of the petition. Futhermore, please submit evidence to establish the number of
times the beneficiary's published materials has been cited or used by others. This information can be botained from a website such as SciFinder and Google Scholar, just to name two.

** Please submit any other documentary evidence that will establish that the beneficiary is outstanding in his/her academic field.

所有跟帖： 

• 回複：NSC EB1b收到RFE求助 -alonestar- ♂ (613 bytes) () 05/29/2008 postreply 20:22:52

• 回複：NSC EB1b收到RFE求助 -christmasbox- ♀ (594 bytes) () 05/30/2008 postreply 08:57:43

• 回複：NSC EB1b收到RFE求助 -christmasbox- ♀ (293 bytes) () 05/30/2008 postreply 09:05:19

• 回複：NSC EB1b收到RFE求助 -peacewang- ♂ (3239 bytes) () 05/30/2008 postreply 20:56:07