個人資料
正文

網上帖子誤導公眾關於加拿大難民年度福利的信息

(2025-08-25 07:25:33) 下一個

網上帖子誤導公眾關於加拿大難民年度福利的信息

Marissa Birnie 2025年7月3日

https://www.thecanadianpressnews.ca/fact_checking/online-posts-mislead-about-annual-benefits-for-refugees-in-canada/article_5a269166-4bf4-56f5-8823-3929c32fb452.html

網上帖子誤導公眾關於加拿大難民年度福利的信息 2025年6月5日,星期四,移民、難民和公民事務部長Lena Metlege Diab在渥太華國會山的質詢環節中發言。難民從聯邦政府獲得的直接福利遠低於一些網上帖子的宣傳。加拿大通訊社/Adrian Wyld
一段TikTok視頻聲稱,難民每年從聯邦政府獲得8.2萬加元的免稅福利,而加拿大人平均每年僅獲得6.3萬加元。這種說法具有誤導性。費用明細包括難民抵達加拿大後獲得的臨時住宿,但這筆費用不太可能達到8.2萬加元。雖然難民可以通過聯邦安置援助計劃獲得收入支持,但這種援助是暫時的,每年的金額不會達到8.2萬加元。

謠言
“你知道嗎,你什麽都不做就能從加拿大政府獲得高達 82,000 加元的補助?”一位 TikTok 用戶在 6 月份發布的一段視頻中問道,該視頻的播放量超過 13 萬次。

根據視頻內容,加拿大難民每天從聯邦政府獲得 224 加元,其中包括 140 加元的住宿費和 84 加元的夥食費。

該視頻將難民每年獲得的 82,000 加元與其聲稱的加拿大人平均年收入 63,000 加元進行了比較,以突顯難民與加拿大公民年收入之間的差距。

該謠言還出現在其他社交媒體上,包括 X 平台(前身為 Twitter)和 Facebook。

評級:誤導性
加拿大難民通過加拿大移民、難民和公民部 (IRCC) 管理的聯邦安置援助計劃 (RAP) 獲得援助。

然而,他們抵達加拿大後在臨時住所期間獲得的資金支持不會直接轉入他們的銀行賬戶,而且在大多數情況下,每年不會達到 82,000 加元。

根據移民部長辦公室 2024 年 3 月給國會議員 Lianne Rood 的回複,無論難民申請人如何進入加拿大,入住 IRCC 運營的酒店後,都會獲得住宿和餐飲。

根據 2024 年 1 月的費率,每間客房的平均費用為每晚 140 加元,每位難民申請人每天 84 加元。加起來,費用為 224 加元。

但是,這 140 加元適用於酒店房間,而不是個人。房間可以同時容納多名難民(例如一個家庭),從而降低每人的費用。

IRCC 將臨時住所的標準停留時間設定為一至三周。然而,根據加拿大移民與公民部 (IRCC) 於 2024 年 8 月發布的報告,2023 年的內部數據儀表盤顯示,“全國平均在臨時住房的居住時間為 60 天”,並且“54% 的受訪難民表示居住時間超過一個月”。

這意味著大多數難民在臨時住所的居住時間不足以獲得價值 8.2 萬加元的食物和住房。

那麽,難民實際上得到了什麽呢?

加拿大新聞社於 4 月進行了一項事實核查,調查了類似的關於難民支持金額的誤導性說法,並參考了安大略省 2024 年 9 月的 RAP 費率,以確定難民個人或家庭每月可獲得的福利金額。

RAP 包含兩個部分。第一部分為服務提供商組織提供短期資金,這些組織提供上述臨時住所,並滿足難民抵達加拿大後的其他緊急需求。

一旦難民獲得永久住房,他們就有資格獲得直接經濟援助,包括一次性付款和每月收入補貼,最長可達一年,在“特殊情況下”可獲得兩年,或直至難民能夠自給自足。

按照這些標準,安大略省單身成年人每月最低可獲得約 1,094 加元,而六口之家每月可獲得約 1,700 加元。

具體標準因省而異,家庭、殘疾人士或生育需求者獲得的金額可能更高。

每月援助金包括基本生活必需品、住房、通訊和交通費用,以及最高 200 加元的住房補貼。

這些每月福利通常會以直接存款的形式直接存入難民的銀行賬戶,但普通難民每年獲得的金額遠低於 82,000 加元。

雖然 RAP 援助無需納稅,但如果難民有收入,則必須納稅。加拿大統計局的數據顯示,在“新登陸移民”中,難民抵達加拿大後最有可能報稅,報稅率約為 95%。

根據加拿大統計局的數據,截至 2023 年,加拿大人的平均收入為 59,400 加元。

根據加拿大統計局的數據,在 2022 納稅年度,2011 年至 2021 年期間抵達加拿大的庇護申請人的收入從 19,600 加元到 34,400 加元不等。

Online posts mislead about annual benefits for refugees in Canada

Marissa Birnie  

https://www.thecanadianpressnews.ca/fact_checking/online-posts-mislead-about-annual-benefits-for-refugees-in-canada/article_5a269166-4bf4-56f5-8823-3929c32fb452.html

Online posts mislead about annual benefits for refugees in CanadaMinister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Lena Metlege Diab rises during Question Period on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Thursday, June 5, 2025. Refugees make much less in direct benefits from the federal government than some online posts claim. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld

A TikTok video claimed refugees receive $82,000 in tax-free benefits per year from the federal government, while the average Canadian receives only $63,000. This claim is misleading. The cost breakdown includes temporary accommodation that refugees receive upon arrival in Canada, but the scenario in which this would reach $82,000 is unlikely. While refugees receive income support through the federal Resettlement Assistance Plan, such assistance is temporary and does not amount to $82,000 annually. 

THE CLAIM

"You know you can get up to $82,000 Canadian dollars from Canadian government for doing nothing?" asks a TikTok user in a June video with more than 130,000 plays. 

According to the video, refugees in Canada receive $224 per day from the federal government, including $140 for accommodation and $84 for food. 

The video makes the comparison between the supposed $82,000 refugees receive annually and what it claims is the average Canadian income of $63,000 to highlight the disparity between a refugee versus Canadian citizen's annual income. 

The claim made its way to other social media, including the X platform, formerly Twitter, and Facebook

RATING: Misleading

Refugees in Canada receive assistance through the federal Resettlement Assistance Program (RAP) administered by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC).  

However, the monetary support they receive during their temporary accommodations after arriving in Canada doesn't go directly into their bank accounts and in most cases would not reflect $82,000 annually. 

According to a March 2024 response from the immigration minister's office to MP Lianne Rood, refugee claimants in IRCC-operated hotels are provided with accommodations and meals once relocated, regardless of how they entered Canada. 

The average cost per room was $140 per night per room and $84 per day per claimant, based on January 2024 rates. Added together, the cost amounts to $224. 

However, the $140 applies to hotel rooms, not individuals. Rooms may house several refugees at once — a family, for example — lowering the cost per person. 

The IRCC has set the standard length of stay for temporary accommodations at one to three weeks. However, a 2023 internal dashboard showed "the national average stay in temporary housing was 60 days," and "54 per cent of surveyed refugees reported staying for longer than one month," according to an IRCC report released in August 2024.

That means most refugees aren't staying in temporary accommodations long enough to get $82,000 worth of food and housing. 

So what do refugees actually receive? 

An April fact check from The Canadian Press investigating similar misleading claims about refugee support amounts consulted RAP rates for Ontario in September 2024 to find the monthly benefit amount an individual or family of refugees could receive. 

There are two components to the RAP. The first provides short-term funding to service provider organizations, which deliver the temporary accommodations mentioned above, and cover other immediate needs after refugees arrive in Canada.

Once refugees secure permanent housing, they're eligible for direct financial support – including one-time payments and monthly income support – for up to one year, or two years in "exceptional circumstances," or until a refugee can support themselves.

The minimum monthly payment for a single adult in Ontario going by those rates would be around $1,094 per month, while a family of six could receive around $1,700 monthly. 

Exact rates vary by province and families and people with disabilities or maternity needs could receive more. 

The monthly payment includes money for basic needs, shelter, communication and transportation as well as a housing supplement, which maxes out at $200. 

Those monthly benefits typically go directly to the refugee's bank account as a direct deposit, but the average refugee wouldn't receive anywhere near $82,000 per year. 

While RAP assistance isn't taxable, refugees must pay taxes if they earn an income and, as data from Statistics Canada shows, they are in fact the most likely immigration group among "newly landed immigrants" to file their taxes upon arriving in Canada, at around 95 per cent. 

The average Canadian income as of 2023 was $59,400, according to Statistics Canada. 

In the 2022 tax year, the income of asylum claimants who arrived in Canada between 2011 and 2021 varied from $19,600 to $34,400, according to Statistics Canada.

SOURCES

Claim posted to TikTok June 20, 2025 (archived) and to X June 21, 2025 (archived) and Facebook May 8, 2025 (archived)

Resettlement Assistance Program (RAP) Service Provider Handbook. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada via Government of Canada website. Accessed July 2, 2025 (archived)

Reply from immigration minister's office to MP from X May 7, 2024 (archived)

Evaluation of the Refugee Resettlement Program. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada website. August 2024 (archived)

Marissa Birnie. Posts mislead on refugee support amounts. The Canadian Press website. April 24, 2025 (archived)

Ontario Resettlement Assistance Program (RAP) Rates September 01, 2024. Refugee Sponsorship Training Program website. Accessed July 2, 2025 (archived)

Tahsin Mehdi et al. Tax-filing rates of newly landed immigrants in Canada: Trends and insights. Statistics Canada website. Nov. 22, 2023 (archived)

Income of individuals by age group, sex and income source, Canada, provinces and selected census metropolitan areas. Statistics Canada website. May 1, 2025 (archived)

Income of asylum claimants by claim year and tax year, for Canada and provinces, 2022 constant dollars. Statistics Canada website. Dec. 9, 2024 (archived)

ABOUT CANADIAN PRESS FACT CHECKS

You can find out more about The Canadian Press here and about Canadian Press Fact Checks here. To reach our fact-checking team with any tips, corrections or comments, please email us at cpfactcheck@thecanadianpress.com.

[ 打印 ]
評論
目前還沒有任何評論
登錄後才可評論.