隴山隴西郡

寧靜純我心 感得事物人 寫樸實清新. 閑書閑話養閑心,閑筆閑寫記閑人;人生無虞懂珍惜,以沫相濡字字真。
個人資料
  • 博客訪問:
文章分類
歸檔
正文

In 1645, English Revolution, generals Thomas Fairfax and Oliver

(2024-01-14 15:47:15) 下一個

Sir Alec Guinness`s performance in :Cromwell (1971)

*** 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqxczRgIDeE&t=21s 

 

The Death of a King - Charles I - Elizabeth I - Full Movie in French (War, Historical) - HD

605,683 views Oct 15, 2023
In 1645, in the midst of the English Revolution, two men, generals Thomas Fairfax and Oliver Cromwell, rose up and overthrew King Charles I, who then ruled as an all-powerful monarch. The best full films? They are HERE http://bit.ly/39AXSat However, Cromwell's plans were far more radical. He orders the execution of the King, takes power and is appointed Lord Protector for life of the Republic of England. His armies spread violence and fear throughout the country. Then began 10 years of absolute dictatorship. By Mike Barker By Jenny Mayhew With Tim Roth, Dougray Scott, Rupert Everett

 

Whether a film is "good" or "bad" is subjective. However I'm about half way through not knowing if I'll finish. It doesn't have to be historically accurate, could even be porn, but I suggest it should be more accurate. Neither mention of the Catholic v. Protestant schism which was a main motivator. E.g. Charles 1 Catholic wife and her influence, not mentioned at all. Nor European context like 100 Years War. Nor fact that Cromwell as a great soldier. Who really knew how to train and organise, especially Cavalry. Treated his men well. Which was "revolutionary", way ahead of his time. 10,000 cavalry might be very expensive to recreate. Yet if portrayed, and with the real honest schisms might help reveal some of the origins of freedoms enjoyed these days in UK, and to some extent in USA and erstwhile British Empire. (Which illegal boat migrants know all about, appear to clamour for, and are thus rewarded?). Perhaps BBC, M&S, etc., should do a remake and cast Charles 1 and or Oliver as black?

 

Charles 1st has nothing to do with Elizabeth 1st! Two different royal houses and 30 years apart

 

Why the "Charles I - Elizabeth I" in the title ? Elizabeth I died 22 years BEFORE Charles 1 became King. Tim Roth does not make a realistic Cromwell. He isn't helped in that role by the weak, shallow dialogue scripted for him.

[ 打印 ]
閱讀 ()評論 (0)
評論
目前還沒有任何評論
登錄後才可評論.