But Luck also had a Rush TD and run 30yards in 4 tries. Manning was 1 for -1.
Quite a few commentator mentioned Luck has an extra dimention (moving and running) that Manning doesn't have.
People have watched Manning play for a long time. THey have lots of respects for Manning (which he has earned).
It is not easy for them to say Luck outplays Manning. But everyone said the same.