I'm very glad for your paper,but I'm right & you are ...

"But I think it is wrong.  From x^x^x... convergent, you cannot get x=x^x.  Let's say x=.5.  .5, .5^.5, .5^.5^.5,... is convergent because it is increase and smaller than 1^.5^.5..., which is 1.  But you cannot say .5=.5^.5."

your .5=.5^.5 is wrong, should be x=x^x, what is x, x is the limit, it is not .5.

let me tell you the detail,(not real Math):

x= .5^.5^.5^.5^.......^.5^.5^.5^.5^.5^......=x^x.

This is not strict Math,but good for understanding.

 

所有跟帖： 

• 回複：I'm very glad for your paper,but I'm right & you are ... -yma16- ♂ (323 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 11:56:42

• Yes,you're right. -jinjing- ♀ (316 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 13:07:13

• some calculators do not compute ^ correctly. -yma16- ♂ (378 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 17:39:10

• Hi,If you try a<1,It convergent very fast. -jinjing- ♀ (130 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 20:43:03

• 回複：Yes,you're right. -yma16- ♂ (414 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 18:30:27

• 回複：回複：Yes,you're right. -jinjing- ♀ (205 bytes) () 01/16/2011 postreply 21:05:36

• I have to say I disagree with you. -yma16- ♂ (933 bytes) () 01/17/2011 postreply 09:51:33

• Thanks,but you are...,Newton was not clear,...100 more years Cau -jinjing- ♀ (287 bytes) () 01/17/2011 postreply 11:12:12

• When I can't your thanks, I check my answer again,my god...... -jinjing- ♀ (846 bytes) () 01/18/2011 postreply 12:31:15

• 回複：When I can't your thanks, I check my answer again,my god..... -yma16- ♂ (548 bytes) () 01/18/2011 postreply 14:22:39

• My friend,you'r great,a>e^(1/e) An is divergent. Why?Because... -jinjing- ♀ (127 bytes) () 01/18/2011 postreply 17:57:16

• thank you for the effort. This is the only -yma16- ♂ (450 bytes) () 01/20/2011 postreply 18:27:29

• Thanks,you are right. A old want to say....why the big one is no -jinjing- ♀ (302 bytes) () 01/21/2011 postreply 10:53:30

• I also found another example that taking a limit -yma16- ♂ (373 bytes) () 01/21/2011 postreply 17:42:54