【非文青N周一文】批判地讀Outliers by Malcolm Gladwell

來源: 非文學青年 2012-10-20 09:20:42 [] [博客] [舊帖] [給我悄悄話] 本文已被閱讀: 次 (4153 bytes)
本文內容已被 [ 非文學青年 ] 在 2012-10-20 09:52:02 編輯過。如有問題,請報告版主或論壇管理刪除.

 

 

In Outliers: The Story of Success, Malcolm Gladwell eloquently argues that those successful people “might have looked as if they rose from nothing, but they are the beneficiaries of hidden advantages, extraordinary opportunities and cultural legacies”.  He starts with showing the pattern that almost all successful Canadian hockey players were born in the first half of the year. They are top players because the cutoff date for picking young hockey players is January, 1st. Kids born in the first half of the year get the advantage of being more mature and more skilled compared to those born in the second half of the year, when a couple of months difference in age still counts. Therefore, they get more encouragement, more positive feedback and more attention, which contribute to their ultimate success in this sport. He claims this trend applies to academic success as well.  This is very relevant to me because my daughter was born on the cutoff date of school enrollment. I had assumed that she had the advantage of choosing to go with either the younger kids or the older ones. Before reading the book, I had leaned toward putting her in the class of the older kids as that had been my own experience, being the youngest in the class. The conclusion from the book makes me hesitatant. I only wish he had seen and reported a study that checks if this trend is true across genders, or to use some statistical jargon, whether gender is a confounding factor in the relationship between age and academic success.

            A month ago, I was just telling NewVoice that I couldn’t think of one single book that had changed my life.  Here you go, now I am thinking, here is a book that will change at least my daughter’s life if we decide against putting her in with the older crowd.  As a chain reaction, it would change my life too. I was pretty convinced by Gladwell’s other claims in the book, like the one about putting 10,000 hours into a skill in order to master it. That sounds like a lot of Chinese proverbs about diligence.  However, I changed my mind about Gladwell’s writing when I came across his theory about rice farming:

            “The peasants of Europe worked essentially as low-paid slaves of an aristocratic landlord, with little control over their own destinies. But China and Japan never developed that kind of oppressive feudal system, because feudalism simply can’t work in a rice economy.”

            Unless there were two different systems both called “feudalism” (hello?!), Chinese society was a feudalistic one for thousands of years.  Gladwell has romanticized rice farming a bit too much, oblivious of the complicated Chinese social and historical environment several centuries ago. This argument was so oversimplified that it made me less convinced about his claim of the advantage of going to school as the older one in the class. Now, I am back to square one, still not sure whether to send my daughter to school when she is five or six.  

Gladwell’s books are, as a lot of reviewers said, both entertaining and enlightening. Just as in Blink, he is a master at weaving facts, anecdotes and theories together to convince his readers. He is very persuasive in general.  Only in this case, I was trying to decide on something that he didn’t really answer. To be fair, it wasn’t his intention to answer that specific question anyway, since the theme of the book is that, what makes someone succeed lies in where he or she is from, when he or she was born, what kind of family he or she was born into and his or her upbringing.

所有跟帖: 

原來青兒去讀[Outliers]了,佩服青兒的文筆,是如此的流暢地道。 -祤湫霖- 給 祤湫霖 發送悄悄話 祤湫霖 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 09:50:07

謝謝紫兒一貫的鼓勵!周末愉快! -非文學青年- 給 非文學青年 發送悄悄話 非文學青年 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 10:03:42

謝校長分析!學習了。 -sportwoman- 給 sportwoman 發送悄悄話 sportwoman 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 10:36:07

great writing, wenqing! -同學小薇- 給 同學小薇 發送悄悄話 同學小薇 的博客首頁 (134 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 11:09:41

take your time, 薇薇,we are not in a rush. -非文學青年- 給 非文學青年 發送悄悄話 非文學青年 的博客首頁 (49 bytes) () 10/21/2012 postreply 14:47:30

崇拜啊,太能寫了! -tingfeng- 給 tingfeng 發送悄悄話 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 12:29:08

WQ在向評論員邁進!寫的太好了,了不起! -rockcurrent- 給 rockcurrent 發送悄悄話 rockcurrent 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 12:40:28

評論的好專業,好大的詞匯量,俺不得不查字典。。一如既往的蔥白。。 -beautifulwind- 給 beautifulwind 發送悄悄話 beautifulwind 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/20/2012 postreply 22:24:25

批判得好! -NewVoice- 給 NewVoice 發送悄悄話 NewVoice 的博客首頁 (1467 bytes) () 10/21/2012 postreply 09:03:46

Sis, I agree with you. -非文學青年- 給 非文學青年 發送悄悄話 非文學青年 的博客首頁 (144 bytes) () 10/21/2012 postreply 14:50:45

有統計顯示事業成功和詞匯量成正比. 對了,這跟貼該不該用英文? -福教授- 給 福教授 發送悄悄話 福教授 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/21/2012 postreply 09:23:02

多謝樓上各位童鞋和新聲姐姐,福教授回帖和鼓勵。 -非文學青年- 給 非文學青年 發送悄悄話 非文學青年 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/21/2012 postreply 14:46:25

請您先登陸,再發跟帖!

發現Adblock插件

如要繼續瀏覽
請支持本站 請務必在本站關閉/移除任何Adblock

關閉Adblock後 請點擊

請參考如何關閉Adblock/Adblock plus

安裝Adblock plus用戶請點擊瀏覽器圖標
選擇“Disable on www.wenxuecity.com”

安裝Adblock用戶請點擊圖標
選擇“don't run on pages on this domain”