涅高茲大師(Heinrich Neuhaus)彈奏肖邦第一鋼協第二樂章(Romance)

這個演奏遠高於現代的演奏. 演奏家最終還是有自己的聲音,體現的是自己的質地.
不愧為俄羅斯學派的一代宗師,教出了Gilels,Richter,Zak,Lupu等大家.
這裏表現情感是古典裏的高貴(nobleness),而不是流行的那種恨不得開腸剖腹似的傾訴.
後者其實是把握不了自己的表現力而嘩眾取寵,似乎是和肥皂劇爭市場.
亞洲男演奏家繼續那樣, 會成為笑柄.

[julia42163]

非常感謝, 你的posting. 讚同你的觀點

[種菜得菜]

回複weston的評論:
此曲油管裏麵能找到的所有我已都聽過，還聽過傅聰的。很期待聽到尚未聽過的。

[weston]

回複種菜得菜的評論:
哪天有空我把幾個前輩大師的上了到時候再華山論劍.

[種菜得菜]

One of the most beautiful Chopin piano pieces, it's so moving that is completely beyond my ability to describe. I was listening to same piece by Emil Gilels almost every day in the past few weeks and thought it was the best version I've ever listened. Well,the Neuhaus's recording you posted here is equally impressive and admirable.

Have to say that Lang Lang's play of this piece is not that bad at all comparing to the rest performers out there (the young generation). Here is the link of Lang Lang's play I watched http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aM3t8_iES24 (containing Romance)

[britannica]

肥皂劇爭市場:))

是啊，音樂本身的表現力才重要。