Tesla is once again leading the pack VW stand a decent chance

Wall Street analysts tore down 7 competing electric-vehicle batteries — and say Tesla is once again leading the pack

Graham Rapier

Sat, October 24, 2020, 8:02 AM EDT

 

• Tesla's held a comfortable lead on electric-vehicle manufacturing and sales for years, after virtually inventing the industry on its own. 

• But now it's not the only player in town, and competitors are quickly catching up, according to UBS. 

• To understand manufacturing costs and technology, analysts at the bank tore down seven battery models used by various competitors.

• They found Tesla still has a comfortable lead and continues to out-innovate, but said companies like Volkswagen stand a decent chance of catching up soon. 

The competition in electric vehicles comes down to one thing: batteries.

To better understand who's employing the best batteries on its cars — and how much they're spending to do it — analysts at the investment bank UBS compared seven cells from all major manufacturers, including Tesla and its suppliers, as well as those for Volkswagen, General Motors, Toyota, BMW, and more.

Perhaps unsurprisingly based on pasts tests, Tesla once again came out on top by most measures. But because it relies on suppliers like CATL, LG Chem, and Panasonic who also supply other automakers, the lead is only slim, UBS says. 

"While Tesla continues to lead with the best overall powertrain technology," the analysts write, "the cost lead in battery cells is minor by now and will depend on its new proprietary cell design in the future."

And after Tesla posted record profits earlier this week, UBS says the company has likely lowered its battery costs even further since it completed its study. That was a charge issued by Elon Musk at Tesla's "Battery Day," when he outlined a plan to in-source battery production and further drive down costs.

"We've got to get the cost of batteries down," Musk told investors in September. "We've got to make — and we've got to be better at manufacturing, and we need to do something about this curve."

That's not just a Tesla problem, even if competitors try to copy things like its cylindrical cell design, as UBS predicts. Allied Market Research predicts the market for the lithium-ion batteries used in EVs will grow more than three-fold by 2027, from $36.7 billion in 2019 to $129.3 billion.

And the only way for anyone to catch up, in UBS' eyes, will be to go all-in like Volkswagen.

"A steep cost reduction curve in combination with an ever-improving regulatory environment in favor of EVs makes it a necessity for auto companies to pursue an 'all-in' EV strategy, meaning that purely CO2-compliance strategies are likely to fail," UBS said.

"Tesla will likely remain the cost and technology benchmark for several more years, and Volkswagen is the fastest follower on a global scale. Its €33bn committed EV investments of over a 5-year period are still unmatched."