李楊對比

Aspect

Tsung-Dao Lee

Chen-Ning Yang

Lifespan

1926–2024 (died August 4, 2024)

1922–2025 (died October 18, 2025)

Key Joint Contribution

Parity violation in weak interactions (1956, with Yang): Proved weak force (e.g., beta decay) doesn’t conserve parity, overturning symmetry assumptions. Nobel Prize 1957.

Same as Lee: Parity violation was a shared breakthrough, experimentally confirmed by Chien-Shiung Wu. Nobel Prize 1957.

Key Solo Contributions

- Lee model (quantum field theory, 1954). - Non-topological solitons. - CP violation insights; statistical mechanics (e.g., lattice QCD). - Supernova neutrino physics; mentorship at Columbia.

- Yang-Mills theory (1954, with Robert Mills): Non-Abelian gauge theory, foundational to the Standard Model (QCD, electroweak force). - Yang-Baxter equation (statistical mechanics). - Condensed matter and integrable systems.

Awards & Recognition

Nobel Prize (1957); Albert Einstein Award (1994); over 30 honorary degrees; China’s Science & Technology Award (2010).

Nobel Prize (1957); Rumford Prize (1980, for Yang-Mills); National Medal of Science (1986); Benjamin Franklin Medal ( Ascoli Prize (2000).

Global Ranking (Physicists)

~Top 20–40 (Pantheon ranks him 311th among 851 physicists by historical popularity; less cited in meta-lists than Yang).

~Top 20–30 (Pantheon ranks him 269th; more frequent in top-50 lists, e.g., Discover Magazine, Quora).

Influence & Legacy

Broad impact in particle physics, astrophysics, and education; founded China’s CUSPEA program for global talent exchange. Less cited for solo theoretical breakthroughs than Yang.

Yang-Mills theory is a cornerstone of modern physics (QCD, electroweak unification); described as a “stylist” by Dyson, rivaling Dirac’s elegance.

Publication Output

~150 papers; influential in neutrino physics and education.

Over 200 papers; deeper theoretical impact in gauge theories and mathematical physics.

Cultural Impact (China)

Iconic figure; inspired Chinese physics community; CUSPEA sent ~900 students abroad.

Similar iconic status; seen as a symbol of Chinese excellence; influenced policy (e.g., Deng Xiaoping’s science focus).

 

所有跟帖: 

李排名前一點 -青柏- 給 青柏 發送悄悄話 青柏 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/19/2025 postreply 11:49:02

楊強一點,20-40vs 20-30 -外鄉人- 給 外鄉人 發送悄悄話 外鄉人 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/19/2025 postreply 11:52:09

那楊還和李爭個啥排名?比人家強就該謙讓一點 -青柏- 給 青柏 發送悄悄話 青柏 的博客首頁 (0 bytes) () 10/19/2025 postreply 13:10:13

請您先登陸,再發跟帖!