>>>it is indeed unfair treatment for this alien subject who respect laws more than most people. For example, when he received lay-off notice around 5pm on 11/14/2011 upexpectly, he quickly fine I-539 for H-4 on the next morning (11/15/2011) using Certified express mail service.
Is this "He" you?
Do you mean 2010?
Did you file H-4 application or not, and what is the outcome?