(NIW) 幫忙看看這4，5個獨立推薦人夠分量了沒？

1， NYU 教授，美國一個影響因子7-8 生物雜誌的主編， 其他還有一堆頭銜。

2，美國一個專業學術協會(xxxx associataion of America, National office)director, co-ordinator ，但不是學術教授

3，美國一個 consultant who make Evaluation research, grant writing, and strategic planning for state governments and non-profit organizations. including for XXXXX's Disease Society of America,社會學博士。

4， 英國 editor of one of the world's leading online pharmaceutical news publications. Before becoming a journalist, He spent several years doing drug discovery research at Oxford University. During the course of my current work, I read a great number of academic research articles。 不是學術教授

這幾個獨立推薦人中，隻有第一個是學術教授，其他都是專業協會負責人或者雜誌編輯等等。大家覺得我的獨立推薦人夠分量嗎？別人好像都找學術上的獨立推薦人。

謝謝給點意見。

所有跟帖： 

• good enough！try to get their CVs. -pharmacyelite- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/20/2007 postreply 21:32:06

• Recommendation outside US may not be strong for NIW? -Squarepants- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 04:18:01

• 謝謝樓上兩位，CV都有了 -jnjose- ♀ (0 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 07:18:01

• one British editor is OK. Curious, what' sthe leading... -pharmacyelite- ♂ (33 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 07:18:12

• 回複：one British editor is OK. Curious, what' sthe leading... -jnjose- ♀ (30 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 07:27:31

• 麻煩再問一下pharmacyelite -jnjose- ♀ (78 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 07:31:25

• I believe their titles are good enough. -pharmacyelite- ♂ (488 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 07:42:19

• pharmacyelite: many thanks for your sincere advices, -jnjose- ♀ (13 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 09:36:13

• 為什麽要，這是不禮貌的事。慎行。且移民局也不需要。 -千裏兔- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 15:18:33

• 回複：為什麽要CV，這是不禮貌的事。慎行。且移民局也不需要。 -千裏兔- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 15:19:43

• not really. Many professors have academic CV, for grants etc. -pharmacyelite- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/22/2007 postreply 09:19:54

• Try your best to your letter to get letters from US govermant ag -Rhodesky- ♂ (0 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 16:36:22

• 回複：Try your best to your letter to get letters from US govermant -rhodesky- ♂ (93 bytes) () 12/21/2007 postreply 16:38:30