AIM-174B vs. R-37M vs. PL-XX。根據ChatGPT,這三者其實是用同樣的方式達到遠射程 …

本帖於 2025-08-30 21:01:28 時間, 由普通用戶 大觀園的賈探春 編輯

The U.S. AIM-174B (air-launched SM-6) has been reported to achieve ranges exceeding 400 km, dramatically greater than the ~240 km range of its ship-launched parent missile. This leap in performance is rooted in launch physics: the advantage of altitude, forward velocity, and trajectory freedom when firing from an aircraft. The same principles explain why Russian and Chinese long-range air-to-air missiles advertise extreme reach.

 

 

1. 

AIM-174B (U.S.)

 

 

  • Derived from the SM-6 surface-to-air missile.
  • Air-launch advantages:
    1. Released at altitude (30,000–40,000 ft) → lower drag, higher efficiency.
    2. Launched at near-supersonic speed → “free” kinetic energy.
    3. No vertical-launch penalty → missile immediately flies toward target.
    4. Lofted trajectories in thin air maximize glide before terminal dive.
  •  
  • Estimated range: 400+ km, nearly double the ship-based SM-6.
  • Mission role: long-range fleet defense and very-long-range air-to-air intercepts (e.g., AWACS, tankers).

 

 

 

 

 

2. 

R-37M (Russia)

 

 

  • Very-long-range AAM carried by MiG-31 and Su-35.
  • Reported range: 300–400 km.
  • Launch advantage: MiG-31 can cruise supersonically at high altitude, giving the R-37M a massive kinematic head start.
  • Uses a large solid rocket motor and a lofted ballistic arc to reach extreme range.
  • Role: designed to kill high-value support aircraft (AWACS, tankers, ISR platforms) well before they can threaten Russian airspace.

 

 

 

 

 

3. 

PL-XX (China, sometimes called PL-21)

 

 

  • Still not fully public; believed to be China’s counterpart to R-37M and AIM-174B.
  • Likely designed for launch from J-16 or J-20 fighters.
  • Projected range: 300–400+ km.
  • Expected to employ similar advantages: high-altitude launch, long-burn motor, and lofted trajectory.
  • Target set: U.S. and allied support aircraft in a Western Pacific fight.

 

 

 

 

 

Comparative Takeaway

 

 

While the U.S., Russia, and China have taken different technological paths, the physics is the same:

 

  • Air launch from altitude and speed provides enormous range gains compared to surface launch.
  • All three weapons aim to deny adversaries the use of critical enablers—AWACS, tankers, ISR aircraft—by striking them hundreds of kilometers behind the front line.
  • The AIM-174B stands out because it leverages an existing naval missile (SM-6), giving the U.S. a cost-effective way to field a dual-role weapon for both ships and fighters, with reach beyond 400 km.

 

請您先登陸,再發跟帖!