個人資料
夢逍遙 (熱門博主)
  • 博客訪問:
正文

Abused compassion

(2011-11-09 14:08:02) 下一個
I encountered an experience today which I find difficult to digest.

I always have compassion for the old people in US. Mostly of them are very isolated and lonely, as they do not live with their family. Or they do not wish to disturb their families. From their perspective, they take pride in their independence and take it granted. But as a person grow up with eastern culture, I thought they are poorly treated and need special care.

That intention pushed me to sign up as the volunteer driver for elderlys who cannot drive because of health issues. My duty is to drive them to doctor appointment, day care class, etc. I pictured all those aged people who live alone in their houses with no immediate family around them. It would be my pleasure to help, if I can.

My first experience is to drive an lady to doctor appointment. To my surprised, she lived with her granddaughter. But her granddaughter needs to work so she was unable to took her to the doctor. It was a bit shock for me. Good thing is that the old lady is super polite and sweet. She told the nurses that the volunteers driver stuff is the best thing the senior center had ever done. At least she appreciate it and I was happy.

This morning I drove another lady to the church class. Before my appointment, I called twice last night and this morning. No one answered the phone. As I arrived on time in front of a decent house, a well-dressed mid-aged woman opened the door, together with her mom on the side. I explained that I called but could not reach them, the woman do not seems very pleased. She said I should left her a voice message as her mom do not answer the phone. (Of course I did not know this fact.) She did not say thank you when we left.

On the way to the church, I asked the lady wether her daughter works, her answer is NO. She told me her daughter has 2 children so she is all busy with cleaning and child care stuff. I asked how old the childrens are, the answers is one of them is teenager and another one in elementary school. Immediately I do not feel so right. What the heck am I doing? Am I the Jesus Christ or sth? I have two younger children of my own, and I give up my job because of them. Now I am rushing this morning to drive someone else's mom to a not so close-by city, with her own daughter nicely make up and dressed staying at home enjoying herself?!!

Is that American value should be? Or those people are taking advantage of other person's kindness??

I was told that the old lady has some memory issue so basically I can ignore whatever she says. But after I arrived, she told me to park somewhere with not that friendly tone. When I parked my car, walked to her side, waited for her and tried to offer her some assistance. She asked without looking at me: "am I supposed to give you money or what?"
 
The last sentence she said  is Bye Bye, she did not look at me. I was left alone standing, should I smile or cry, I do not know.

The local senior center spent lots of effort to make the life of elderly people easier. There are a group of volunteer drivers who donate their priceless time and love providing the warmth and conveniency for people in need. I am not blaming the old people, only their families. If their parents live with them, it should be their responsbilities to provide whatever they can to help. They should not put burden on other people. They should not abuse our compassion.

That is also part the reason I never got totally fused into the western cultures. I am always a foreigner on something like that, but I feel proud.

(P.S. I spoke with the coordinator of the senior center. The coordinator called this lady and she agreed to drive her mom to the class in the future. My voice got heard!)





[ 打印 ]
閱讀 ()評論 (9)
評論
laomeng 回複 悄悄話
I am one of the volunteer in a company proj to paint a house for a family. The house was big and was in a not very-good area, it looked that a big family lived there. We have almost 20 volunteers worked for almost one day. To be my surprise, I noticed that there are several young and strong men lived in that house, they did not come out, but no one said thank you either. Of course, no one provided any food/drink or helped.

I understand that the feeling was not good.

hotpepper 回複 悄悄話 回複夢逍遙的評論:
I am on your side as I have similar experience. As I said in another comments, I only encountered half of the people who really need the service. The other half are really social parasites, taking advantage of other people's good heart and will.
hotpepper 回複 悄悄話 The Americans have now a pretty deep rooted entitlement culture that not olny take advantage of tax payers money but also good hearts of people who volunteer. I had similar experience in Michigan. Driving some of the seniors to events because their own children wanted to save gas money. Their believe is "if it is free, why not ask".

The problems are hurting those who really need and appreciate the volunteer service because they do not have any other alternatives. That is only about half of the people I have encounteres. The other half are just social parasites.
龜苓膏 回複 悄悄話 雖然聖經裏總是說要感恩,可是我覺得他們還是很實際的,沒有們那種滴水之恩湧泉相報的慷慨和真誠。
龜苓膏 回複 悄悄話 我覺得你的感覺是正常的,即使沒有說謝謝,一個微笑應該還是有的吧。在第二個例子裏麵,不是他們真正需不需要幫助的問題,是他們不尊重你以及你對他們的幫助。
夢逍遙 回複 悄悄話 回複smeagolrocks的評論:
Thanks. I will not stop. I will help people in need. That will be my pleasure.
Thanks for your kindess as well. Cheers.
smeagolrocks 回複 悄悄話 Like mother, like daughter. I think these people were brought up in a selfish way. They do not really need help. They just took advantage of other people's kindness. Having said that I am sure there are other people who truly really need help. I hope you do not stop doing so just because of the doing of a few unkind people.

I volunteered in a house rebuilding project for an old couple. The husband had cancer in his eyes and lost his vision. While we were fixing their house, the wife made us food and drinks.... We felt our work was realy rewarding.
夢逍遙 回複 悄悄話 回複curry的評論:
Thanks! You are partially right. No human can give unconditional love to others, only the God can.
I do not mind helping people who truly need help. That is the reason i become an volunteer. but some people just took advantage of it. They are lazy and selfish and count on the community to share their
responsibilities. Like some of the homeless people or some people who get food stamp from government. That is my point.
But thanks for your comment. It made me realized how limited the human kindness can be.
curry 回複 悄悄話 I understand your bitterness, but I also feel that you are very calculated, which seems to be a Chinese trait. Your "compassion" is not true compassion. It's only for those who you perceive to be worse off than you. Helping someone, regardless of how well off they seem to be, should bring you inherent happiness, but here you are bitter. Perhaps growing up in China where there's a lot of competition and everyone tries to keep others down made you feel this way.
登錄後才可評論.