Best Landlord Insurance Young Alfred works with the top landlord insurance providers, and we have compiled a list of them below. We can also show you the types of coverage available from each insurance company. Insurance Company | State Coverage | Financial Rating | Market Share | Known For | State Auto | 30 states | AM Best A- | <0.5% | New Tech | Travelers | 50 states | AM Best A++ | 4.08% | Experienced | Hippo | 32 states | AM Best A- | <0.5% | Digital | Progressive | 50 states | AM Best A+ | 1.58% | Established | SafeCo / Liberty Mutual | 50 states | AM Best A | 6.48% | Experienced | Mercury | 11 states | AM Best A | <0.5% | California | Foremost / Farmers | 50 states | AM Best A | 5.71% | Specialty | Openly | 10 states | AM Best A- | <0.5% | Digital | Allstate | 50 states | AM Best A+ | 8.38% | Experienced | TPC | 5 states | AM Best A | <0.5% | Experienced | Velocity | 6 states | AM Best A | <0.5% | Coastal | Tower Hill | 14 states | AM Best B++ | 0.65% | Specialty | Universal P&C | 19 states | Demotech A | 1.17% | Experienced | Kingstone | 4 states | Demotech A | <0.5% | New York | Olympus | 1 state | Demotech A | <0.5% | Florida | Homeowners of America | 5 states | Demotech A | <0.5% | Regional | CA FAIR Plan | 1 state | Government | | California | Citizens | 1 state | Government | | Florida | |