回複:隻看了一張上海樓房倒塌照片,估計問題出在地基處理上。
You are right
The building is good and the foundation itself is fine.
Since most windows did not break, the collapse must be a soft landing (to soft soil surface) which means a slow failure.
Based on the appearances of those pile sections, the failure is not induced by lateral forces or shears.
A few issues may cause the final failure:
1. The weak soil support layer(s) under the foundation (may be partially)drags the build into dislocation
2. The dislocation produces large tensile forces and moments to break the piles in order.