undocumented移民對美國GDP的貢獻知道有多少嗎？交的稅有多少知道嗎？

https://research.newamericaneconomy.org/report/contributions-of-undocumented-immigrants-by-country/

According to budget.house.gov, illegal immigrants may contribute around $321 billion to the US GDP, but this doesn't account for their tax contributions or the benefits they provide to US-born citizens. In fact, some say that illegal immigrants' state tax payments don't cover the costs of their presence, and that they aren't a net economic benefit to the US. However, others say that undocumented immigrants contribute to the economy in many ways, including as workers, consumers, and entrepreneurs.

 

 

Table 3: Top 5 Industries by Share of Workforce, Undocumented Mexican Immigrant, 2019

Industry	Mexican Undocumented Workers	Total Workforce	Share of Workforce
Agriculture	224,000	1,943,000	11.5%
Construction	733,000	11,016,000	6.7%
Tourism, Hospitality, and Entertainment	524,000	15,365,000	3.4%
General and Personal Services	202,000	7,597,000	2.7%
Manufacturing	370,000	15,800,000	2.3%

 

Table 5: Economic Contributions for the Top 5 Countries of Origin Among Undocumented Immigrants, 2019

Country of Origin	Total Household Income (in Millions $)	Federal Income Taxes (in Millions $)	State & Local Taxes (in Millions $)	Spending Power (in Millions $)
Mexico	$91,992	$5,396	$4,391	$82,205
El Salvador	$12,906	$782	$631	$11,493
India	$18,306	$1,965	$840	$15,501
Guatemala	$10,163	$586	$496	$9,082
Honduras	$7,184	$434	$344	$6,406

 

 

美國是合眾國，各個州比較獨立，不喜歡藍州就搬到紅州去，沒人攔著，別委屈自己。