戴榕菁

下麵是在academia.com和來自中國的讀者關於我的“The Faulty System of Relativistic Momentum and Energy【[1]】”一文的對話。

X. D. Dongfang
1 hr ago

The equation (1) in your article is derived from the integral form of the kinetic energy theorem in the sense of relativistic mechanics. Within the framework of relativistic mechanics, it has strict derivation. I seem to have reproduced such derivation in some articles. But relativity is based on the wrong assumption that the speed of light is constant.

Rongqing Dai
31 mins ago

You are wrong!.....Please try to give your derivation without redefining momentum p using (3).....Don't just talk by imagination......Try it using your hands!

了解我的讀者都知道我很反感在對我的文章做評論時不認真讀我的文章而憑想象自以為聰明地胡扯，所以我的語氣不太客氣。

下麵是該文相關部分的截圖：

相關鏈接：
相對論動量和能量的一筆亂賬